The Allegheny Hockey Association was founded in 1992 when the Eastern Hockey Association relocated to a new rink, leaving the Golden Mile Ice Center in Plum without an anchor youth hockey program. To fill that void, the Allegheny Badgers were born.

The Badgers nickname came in honor of Pittsburgh Penguins head coach "Badger" Bob Johnson.  Badger Bob passed away in late 1991, just months after leading the Pittsburgh Penguins to their first Stanley Cup Championship and only a few months prior to Allegheny forming its program.

In 1997, the association moved to a newly-opened facility: Center Ice Arena in Delmont.  The association helped finance an addition to the arena in the early 2000s, and a third sheet of ice -- aptly called the Allegheny Rink -- opened in 2003.  Now called Palmer Imaging Arena, the rink played host to the USA Hockey Youth Tier II 18U National Tournament in 2024.

As one of only three member associations with three ice surfaces at their home facility, the Badgers have grown into one of the largest organizations in the PAHL.  And considerable success has come with that growth, annually winning PAHL banners and putting teams in contention for national tournament bids.  In 2011, the Badgers 18U AA team advanced to the championship game at the USA Hockey National Tournament.